Updates to this story
Facebook is certainly making life difficult for users who want out. Could it be coincidence that a list of changes has appeared following the launch of Google's G+? People are responding well to Google's alternative, and, to us, it looks like Facebook is dabbling in the dark arts to keep its users users, whether they like it or not.
Data is the topic of the hour. People are growingly concerned with who owns our personal data and what they're doing with it. Transparency isn't exactly topping certain company's to-do lists. So you'd like to think that once you sign up to an account with any service, you would have some control over your data. Or at least have the option of removing it without coming up against tricks and cons from the company holding it - your information.
Anyone who has tried to delete their Facebook account recently will probably have noticed it isn't that simple.
Facebook has hidden the 'Permanently delete' option, at least for the average user who doesn't Google everything they don't understand or can't find. Of its userbase, that will be a significant number of people.
When you go to 'Account settings' and then 'Security' you can see the option of deactivating the account. When you click to deactivate, not only do you have to give Zuckerberg a reason, but you have no option on the page to delete the data associated with the account in question.
To the average user, this looks a lot like 'Facebook don't let you delete your account. They only let you deactivate it.'
It looks as though you have no option to delete everything you've got attached to your account. And with some people, that's a lot.
All of those private messages, photo albums and 'likes' still exist when your account is deactivated.
It just means that you are no longer searchable. The account still exists with all that information still attached to it.
With so many people falling for Facebook's questionable cunning, people are manually deleting their albums, content on their wall, and their messages. The messages are the hardest to manually remove.
Did you know that the little 'x' next to your messages no longer means delete? It's now 'archive'. You archive your messages now!
If you want to delete your messages, you have to open them one by one, going through the menu time and time again, and keep hitting the delete button.
If you want to actually delete your Facebook account, you won't find the link anywhere in your account settings. You have to scour the Help Centre for the 'Permanently delete your account' link. Which happens to be here.
You have to submit a request to Facebook to have your information removed and your account deleted. This takes approximately two weeks. If you log into, or use your account in any way, the deletion is cancelled and you will have to resubmit your request to delete all of your personal information.
That includes clicking any 'like' buttons, logging in to your account or logging into Facebook chat on external clients. Does facebook log in automatically on your phone? Opening that will reactivate it, too.
Anyone would think Facebook is scared of losing users to Google+. Which happens to be why TechEye got its magnifying glass out and went on the trail. A lot of people are talking a lot about how to delete their accounts. Or at least thinning data out before deleting at a later date. Clearly, it's not that easy. Why?
Will anyone who wants to delete their account, be strong enough to migrate without looking back?
It's matter of time, it will always be.
On the other hand, what are the reasons that someone would actually want to delete all of the account?
I know that most of my FaceBook photos (and personal memories) are made up of other peoples photos that are shared on FaceBook and that I have been tagged in.
It seems to me that the majority of people leaving FaceBook SHOULD deactivate their account as apposed to completely deleting it. Completely deleting it would mean deleting chunks out of many peoples albums.
Its comparable to how after posting this message (and any others on this site) I won't have the option to easily remove them all at once.
Or erm, +1! :)
_"If you log into, or use your account in any way, the deletion is cancelled and you will have to resubmit your request to delete all of your personal information."_ - *why are you logging into your account if you're trying to delete it?*
"That includes clicking any 'like' buttons, logging in to your account or logging into Facebook chat on external clients." - *if you're logged out of your fb account, clicking a 'like' button will prompt you with a facebook login screen ... um, duh!! See comment above. I understand the point about 3rd party apps that might log you in without at first knowing .... if you're that concerned about your data, do a little homework on which services are logging you into facebook. Again, duh!!*
"Does facebook log in automatically on your phone? Opening that will reactivate it, too." - *Again, why do you have fb on your phone if you're trying to deactivate your account?*
Does this Rebecca Baker make a living out of writing tech articles? This is a news article? Wow.
Money.
How is Facebook making money? What uses do they have for all that data you provide them? Who has legal rights to that data? What moral or ethical situations arise from this?
These are questions I think many would like to see answered.
That all changed when I learned the facts in this article. There have been countless polls that show that most of Facebook's users hate it, that it has a relations problem with them. Now something as good as Facebook comes along and Facebook responds not by innovating but by churlishly clinging to its users with spiteful tricks like those listed in the article. All they're doing is exacerbating their poor public image and perversely making their site harder to use.
This is why I both predict and hope that this will only cause their users to jump ship quicker than before.
That's not exactly true. If you log into your Facebook account after you request it to be deleted, you will be prompted to make one of two choices: Cancel the deletion, or Confirm the deletion. If you confirm the deletion, you will be logged back out of Facebook, and your account will still be deleted after two weeks.
these options weren't easily available even before that.
some people may actually just want to suspend their account perhaps its easier to make deleting harder than to make data recovery easier.
imagine having your account hacked by x and they want to stuff you around, so before they just delete and boom all gone. now its not that easy.
looks like a smart move to me.
why cant people just see the simplist in things.
Facebook and Google suck. Period.
WOW. I just checked my cookies. Lookie what I found:
Name: reg_ext_ref
Content: http%3A%2F%2Fnews.techeye.net%2Finternet%2Ffacebooks-grip-on-all-of-your-data-exposed
Domain: .facebook.com
Path: /
Send For: Any kind of connection
Accessible to Script: Yes
Created: Tuesday, October 11, 2011 5:46:31 AM
Expires: When I quit my browser
The notable parts are the domain: .facebook.com and the content: http%3A%2F%2Fnews.techeye.net%2Finternet%2Ffacebooks-grip-on-all-of-your-data-exposed.
Facebook knows I read this article. And I don't even have an account.
WOW. I just checked my cookies. Lookie what I found:
Name: reg_ext_ref
Content: http%3A%2F%2Fnews.techeye.net%2Finternet%2Ffacebooks-grip-on-all-of-your-data-exposed
Domain: .facebook.com
Path: /
Send For: Any kind of connection
Accessible to Script: Yes
Created: Tuesday, October 11, 2011 5:46:31 AM
Expires: When I quit my browser
The notable parts are the domain: .facebook.com and the content: http%3A%2F%2Fnews.techeye.net%2Finternet%2Ffacebooks-grip-on-all-of-your-data-exposed.
Facebook knows I read this article. And I don't even have an account.