There I was, minding my own business, as usual, working not out of my wireless cave that day, but in my local internet cafe, since I don't own a computer and do all my email and surfing chores at the rent-a-computer cafe down the street from the place where I live.
I prefer renting. So every day, without fail, I make my way to the Dragon Fruit Tattoo Internet Cafe
in my little burg in southern Taiwan, without fail, I commence reading and typing for an hour or two until the money runs out and I need to put in some more coins.
This system might not work for everyone, but it keeps me sane.
However, speaking of sanity, the other day something entirely baffling happened and I still don't get it.
There I was on Facebook, madly typing away to someone named Mad Mike Mageek, but before I could send my FB message, the machine asked for to fill in the Captcha security box and type in two words. The words are usually English words, in fact, they have always been English words.
The Captcha box will ask you to type in, say, "deer" and "tailgate" and then you're on your way.
But this time, just the other day, here in Taiwan, the Captcha people sent me a Captcha box that asked me to type in one word that was printed in English and another word which was printed in Hebrew!
Yes, Hebrew letters, Hebrew script, the aleph beth gimmel of the Hebrew alphabet. Though it's true I can read and decipher Hebrew, having studied it as a kid at my local synagogue and passed all the tests that allowed me to become a bar mitzvah boy at age 13 in the Boston area, I have no idea how to type Hebrew on a computer. And my computer here only does English and Chinese. Not Hebrew.
So not only was I flabberghasted, I was also perplexed and flummoxed.
Thus began this journey.
I asked around. My friends and email pals near and far joked that now maybe Facebook could actually peer into a our private lives and know which religion we followed as kids or which New Age cult we were into as adults.
But no, Facebook has no way of knowing I am Jewish, do they? Mark Zuckerberg, are you looking over my shoulder again?
Said a professor at the Annenberg School for Communication at the University of Pennsylvania: "This Captcha gaffe, or glitch, is very interesting. They must have thought that you were in Israel rather than Taiwan."
David Rothman, a novelist in Washington, D.C., author of "The Solomon Scandals" and a founder of Teleread.org, noted with Jewish humor: "Facebook or the Captcha people must have ways of remotely X-raying you to see if you've been circumcised. That's it."
So I wrote to the Captcha people after locating their offices somewhere at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburg, and I received this nice note:
"Dear Dan Bloom,
You got a reCaptcha.
The Hebrew word must have been from some text that OCR (Optical Character Recognition) was having trouble reading. Anyone could have got it.
It's just a coincidence that you could read Hebrew (and that the word translates to "book").
Our Captchas do not yet make use of their uncanny ability to tell what languages its clients (like you) know."
Notice he jokingly, yet somewhat ominously, said that "Captchas do not yet make use of their uncanny ability to tell what languages its [individual] clients know."
I am worried. Should I be? Tell me in plain English!
while ago about recaptcha and was shocked to discover that my efforts to
reproduce those words were being used for scholarly purposes. Now I feel a
sense of responsibility every time I encounter one.
Here’s a podcast on captchas that I heard recently.
http://howtodoeverything.org/post/4583502151/how-to-get-past-a-captcha-you-cant-read-rescue
Hideo in Tokyo, reading from afar.....
This is what happened. You got what we call a 'reCaptcha'.
RE-CAPTCHA. The Hebrew word is from some text that OCR (Optical
Character Recognition) was having trouble reading on your computer in
Taiwan. Anyone could have got it. It's just a coincidence that you
being Jewish and having gone to Hebrew School at a kid in the 1950s
could read Hebrew (and that the word translates to "book"). However,
please know thatg our Captchas do not yet make use of their uncanny
ability to tell what languages its clients (like you) know.
Best,
SIGNED
Dr Manuel Blum, Carnagie Mellon University, USA
dunno....
most people use REcaptcha because it works better
11:30 PM me: friend in USA tells me ''Very interesting. They must have thought you were in Israel rather than Taiwan.''
Joey: Yeah, it's usually based upon geoIp
geo IP
there is a program which looks up your IP address and determines where in the world you are
the other way is via browser settings
but since not all browsers expose that, some folks rely on geoip
11:31 PM me: so in taiwanm sometimse the CAPTHCA will be in CHinese? i never saw that yet.....why Hebrew? in TAiwan? as i halluncaitng mayu\b?
maybe
11:36 PM Joey: Yeah I would expect Taiwan to render as simplified chinese
not Hebrew
11:37 PM me: this in confusing even for Confucius!
11:38 PM Joey: Unless it keeps happening I think it's probably a glitch
11:39 PM me: must be... a glitch.....never never saw that before or ever again i am sure....but wow,,,how did it happen? it wasn't two words in Hebrwe, it was ONE word in English, normal and one wotrd in Hebrew.....funny and unexpeted...i am writing now tot he Capth wirzrds at UPENN...
Joey: the other thing to note is that captcha uses project guttenberg text
11:40 PM Joey: so it's possible they scanned a book and mislabeled it as english
Joey: or it's a line in hebrew that appears in an english book
me: aha...i think you are very WARM! yes
> Please remove me from these emails.
> Thank you
i will remove you from my emails as soon as you or Dr Blum answer my question, I am reportign this story..
On Wed, Jun 22, 2011 at 11:04 PM, Nicole Stenger
Think of all the people of Hellenic descent who find Greek characters in their capchas. The personalization of the Web makes these concerns inevitable. See
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/23/opinion/23pariser.html
]2 Feb 2009 – This Captcha generator is intended to filter non-Hebrew speakers from Hebrew sites. Antisemitic forum spam is a well-known problem. ...
billauer.co.il/hebrew_captcha_securimage.html
]Lanapsoft BotDetect CAPTCHA Hebrew localization details.
captcha.biz/localizations/hebrew-captcha.html
If you’ve ever registered for a site or an email list, you’re surely familiar with those frustrating anti-spam CAPTCHA forms. CAPTCHA, which is an acronym for “Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart,” generally does a really good job of blocking … me:
Captured By CAPTCHA (Limerick)
By Madeleine Begun Kane
The CAPTCHA form used on their site
Quickly conquered computerized blight,
Because bots can’t decode
Any image it showed.
But then neither can I—there’s my plight
(You can find more of my technology humor here.)
Tags: Bot Humor, CAPTCHA, Forms, Internet Humor, Site Registration, Spam Humor, Technology Satire
Just a guess....